Download Fitness Tools

Is Intermittent Fasting "Diabesity Incompatible"? Increase in Glucose Excursions (+20-40%) + Impaired Insulin Response During Lunch and Dinner After Skipping Breakfast in T2DM

Whether having breakfast will help or hinder glucose control will also depend on its macronutrient composition and carbohydrate content. In their 2011 study Pereira et al. were able to show that a high carbohydrate, high GI breakfast will have a similarly negative impact on glucose control of adults and children as having no breakfast at all (Pereira. 2011).

Intermittent fasting (IF), i.e. skipping breakfast and/or other meals in order to stay fasted for ~16h+ per day is no longer "all the rage", but still highly popular among people who believe in its health and weight loss benefits. And in fact, there is some research (also from a couple of Ramadan studies) that appears to confirm the notion that it is healthy and may - even without deliberate caloric restriction - facilitate weight and more importantly fat loss.

On the other hand, intermittent fasting conflicts with everything we've been (falsely?) told about the benefits of frequent meals. Benefits of which waredownloadsoft readers know that they are quasi-non-existent, in most healthy individuals and sometimes even counter-productive in obese and diabetic individuals, where most studies refute that eating more frequently provides significant weight loss benefits in the context of a calorically restricted diet.
Now, a recent study from the Diabetes Unit, Wolfson Medical Center of the Sackler Faculty of Medicine at the Tel Aviv University, the Lund University in Sweden and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (Jakubowicz. 2015) suggests that extending your overnight fast by skipping breakfast may have real (not just corollary) detrimental effects on habitual breakfast eaters (learn why this is important) who are suffering from type II diabetes (with glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) levels of 7–9% (the subjects in the study at hand were more than just pre-diabetic).

In this group of subjects, skipping breakfast increases post-prandial hyperglycemia (PPHG) after lunch and dinner. It lowers the important GLP-1 response to the meals (learn more about how GLP-1 is important in "Eat More, Burn More and Lose Fat Like on Crack with GLP-1!?") and impairs the subjects' already messed up insulin response. More specifically,

• Three meals may be ok, but six meals are actually counterprodutive in T2DM.

  the lunch AUC0-180 for glucose, FFA, and glucagon were 36.8, 41.1 and 14.8% higher, respectively, and the AUC0-180 for insulin and  iGLP-1 17.0% and 19.0% lower, respectively, on the NoB[reakfast] day compared with the YesB[reakfast] day (P < 0.0001), 
• the dinner AUC0-180 for glucose, FFA, and glucagon were 26.6, 29.6, and 11.5% higher, respectively, and the the AUC0-180 for insulin and iGLP-1 were 7.9% and 16.5% lower on the NoB day compared with the YesB day (P < 0.0001), on the other hand

Whether the conclusion that "[b]reakfast consumption could be a successful strategy for reduction of PPHG [prostprandial hyperglycemia] in type 2 diabetes" applies to every type II diabetic is yet as questionable as the assumption that you could extrapolate the data from this acute phase study and use it to predict the long-term response in diabetics, let alone health individuals.

Figure 2: Hunger, satiety, plasma glucose and insulin in the Eaters and Skippers in the two conditions in Thomas (2015).

If we go back to Thomas' recently published study (I have discussed it in detail here), it is after all obvious that the scientists choice of subjects who consume breakfast regularly may have thwarted their results. I mean, the researchers from the University of Colorado School of Medicine and the Denver Health Medical Center have shown quite conclusively that one's breakfast habits will determine whether skipping breakfast increases insulin, hunger and blood lipids or not.
References: